What To Buy: Hyundai Exter vs Chery Tiggo 4 vs Nissan Magnite
How well does the new Hyundai Exter stack up against best-selling budget crossovers such as the Chery Tiggo 4 Pro and Nissan Magnite? More importantly, which one of these cars represents the strongest buying proposition? Let’s find out!
The new Hyundai Exter has been in high demand since it arrived on the local market in September 2024. That’s good news for Hyundai, because this segment is jam-packed with strong products. As it stands, the Chery Tiggo 4 Pro, Nissan Magnite, Suzuki Fronx, Renault Kiger and Toyota Starlet Cross are among the best-selling budget crossovers. Mahindra also recently joined the party with the new XUV 3XO!
Suffice it to say, buyers are spoilt for choice in this segment and this article will examine how the new Hyundai Exter stacks up against the popular Chery Tiggo 4 Pro and the Nissan Magnite.
Also see: What to Buy: Suzuki Fronx vs Chery Tiggo 4 Pro vs Nissan Magnite
The main aim of this article is to help you, the consumer, make an informed buying decision. To help you do this, we will provide you with the need-to-know information and insight based on available vehicle information and our experience with the cars in question.
This article will cover key aspects such as Performance & Efficiency, Interior Features & Safety, Dimensions & Practicality, as well as Pricing & Warranty details.
If, at the end of this article, you are still undecided as to what to buy, you are more than welcome to reach out to us for advice via X, Facebook or Instagram. Our experienced test team will gladly assist you.
What To Buy: Hyundai Exter vs Chery Tiggo 4 vs Nissan Magnite
Performance
| Hyundai Exter | Chery Tiggo 4 Pro | Nissan Magnite | |
| Powertrain | 1.2-litre, naturally aspirated petrol | 1.5-litre naturally aspirated petrol 1.5-litre, turbocharged, petrol | 1.0-litre naturally-aspirated 1.0-litre, turbocharged petrol |
| Power Output | 61 kW (NA) | 83 kW (NA) 108 kW (Turbo) | 53 kW (NA) 74 kW (Turbo) |
| Torque Output | 114 Nm (NA) | 138 Nm (NA) 210 Nm (Turbo) | 96 Nm (NA) 160 Nm (Turbo) |
| Transmission | 5-speed manual / 5-speed automated manual (AMT) | 6-speed manual / CVT | 5-speed (manual) / 5-speed automated manual (AMT) / CVT / DCT |
| Fuel Consumption | 5.7 – 5.9 L/100 km | 6.7 – 7.0 L/100 km | 5.2 – 6.0 L/100 km |
Hyundai Exter
All Hyundai Exter derivatives are powered by a naturally aspirated 1.2-litre 4-cylinder petrol engine that produces 61 kW and 114 Nm of torque. On paper, its peak outputs are notably better than what’s offered by the equivalent Magnite, but it’s not as punchy as the larger capacity engine in the Chery Tiggo 4 Pro.
Thanks to the Exter’s low kerb weight of 957 kg, its engine doesn’t have to work too hard to get the vehicle up to speed. In an urban setting, the Exter’s performance is more than adequate (allied with a responsive steering feel), plus the manual ‘box has a light, but direct action, which will please buyers.
The engine sounds a trifle strained at the national speed limit, which suggests that the gearbox would benefit from having an additional (6th) gear to reduce the engine’s RPM to the benefit of fuel efficiency. With that said, the Exter is more suited to urban- or city driving, as opposed to long-distance touring.
The ride quality is good, considering the Exter’s price point – the Indian-build budget crossover has a forgiving, comfortable suspension setup that can cope with South Africa’s deteriorating road network.
Note that we have yet to drive the Exter AMT, but our experience with automated manual transmissions in other products has been disappointing. While an AMT offers the convenience of 2-pedal driving, that type of transmission is usually paired with a motor that produces limited torque, so shifts need to be timely – but they aren’t always! We reserve judgment on the Exter AMT until we have experienced it.
Good fuel economy is one of the Exter’s strengths; Hyundai claims an average of 5.7 to 5.9 L/100km. On our test drive of a manual Exter, it returned excellent figures of around 6.0 to 6.2 L/100 km.
Chery Tiggo 4 Pro
The naturally aspirated 1.5-litre petrol engine in the Chery Tiggo 4 Pro does offer superior peak engine outputs to the Exter and, if you plan on doing more highway driving over longer distances, perhaps the Chinese offering is a more suitable transport solution.
The Tiggo 4 Pro range also has the option of a 1.5-litre 4-cylinder turbopetrol engine, which is the preferred powertrain for its punchier performance, but only if your budget allows you to purchase a 1.5T-powered derivative, of course. Ride quality is good on well-sealed surfaces, but does deteriorate on poorer surfaces due to insufficient damping. However, if you’re likely to spend most of your time driving in an urban environment (not on gravel), the Tiggo 4 Pro will be adequately refined for this purpose.
Unlike the Exter, the Tiggo 4 Pro is available with a continuously variable transmission (CVT), which is a more refined auto compared with the former’s AMT, but a laid-back driving approach is required to get the best out of a CVT (hard acceleration should be a last resort, not the norm). Chery also offers a dual-clutch transmission (DCT) in the flagship Tiggo 4 Pro Elite, which trumps the CVT if you can afford it.
In exchange for punchier performance, buyers will have to accept higher fuel consumption, which isn’t ideal for a car of this size. Chery claims an average fuel-efficiency of between 6.7- and 7.0 L/100 km, but real-world figures above 8.8 L/100km can be expected.
Nissan Magnite
Nissan expanded the Magnite range in 2023 with the addition of a naturally aspirated 1.0-litre petrol engine with 53 kW and 96 Nm of torque. In the company of the Exter and Tiggo 4 Pro, this engine’s outputs are, well, workmanlike.
Admittedly, we have yet to drive a derivative of the Magnite with this engine, but we can comfortably recommend opting for a turbopetrol variant of this model, again, if your budget allows it. Naturally-aspirated engines lose about 17% of their power at higher altitudes such as in Gauteng and the Magnite, with its low torque output will suffer for that, especially when fully loaded with passengers and luggage.
The turbocharged Magnite does offer better overall performance than its naturally aspirated sibling. However, we have found that this engine is gutless below 2 800 rpm, so you have to gear down often to “keep the engine on the boil” (so to speak) or consider opting for the automatic (CVT) derivative.
Ride quality is fair-to-good, but the cabin insulation could be better (to stop road- and tyre noise from bothering the Magnite’s occupants), something which will hopefully be addressed when the facelifted Nissan Magnite reaches Mzansi. When you corner hard in the Magnite, body roll is also pronounced.
As far as fuel efficiency is concerned, the Magnite returns around 6.5 L/100km in real-world driving situations (Nissan claims an average of between 5.2- and 6.0 L/100 km).
Interior execution and features
For this feature comparison, we will compare the range-topping derivatives from each model range.
Features are easily compared using our handy Compare Tool where you can compare up to 3 cars side-by-side.
See the full specification comparison here
| Hyundai Exter 1.2 Elite | Chery Tiggo 4 Pro 1.5T Elite DCT | Nissan Magnite 1.0 Turbo Acenta Plus auto | |
| Infotainment system | 8-inch touchscreen | 10.25-inch touchscreen | 8-inch touchscreen |
| Digital Instrument Cluster | 4-inch colour TFT display | 7-inch digital cluster | Central digital display |
| Android Auto / Apple CarPlay | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Bluetooth, Voice Control, USB, Wireless Charging | Yes, Type C (front), no wireless charging | Yes, 2 front USB, 1 rear USB, no wireless charging | Yes to all, 1 front USB |
| Rear View Camera | Yes | Yes | Front and Rear, 360-degree |
| Steering Adjustment: Rake / Reach | Rake only | Rake and reach | No |
| Cruise Control | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Air Conditioning | Climate control | Climate control | Climate control |
| Panoramic Sunroof | Tilt sunroof | Sunroof | No |
| Upholstery / electric seats | Partial artificial leather and cloth, manual seats | Leather, electrically adjusted driver’s seat | Partial artificial leather and cloth, manual seats |
| Front / Rear Park Distance Control | Rear only | Rear only | Rear only |
| Safety Features | 6 airbags, ABS with EBD, Stability control (no traction control), tyre pressure monitor | 6 airbags, ABS (no EBD), Electronic Stability Control with traction control, Brake Assist, hill descent control, tyre pressure monitoring | 2 airbags, ABS with EBD, Electronic Stability Control with traction control, hill start assist, tyre pressure monitoring |
Interior feature summary
As Hyundai’s new budget crossover (it’s positioned below the popular Venue small crossover), the Exter features a rudimentary cabin design featuring mostly hard-wearing plastics. While there’s no major wow factor to the Exter’s cabin, it exhibits good perceived build quality and the central 8-inch touchscreen infotainment system is easy to use with an intuitive menu layout. A tilting sunroof adds to the Exter’s charm and it’s worth mentioning that both USB-A and USB-C ports are present to charge your devices.
The Tiggo 4 Pro’s cabin ambience, by comparison, is elevated by soft-touch surfaces and a variety of materials that give it a more stylish look and feel. Perceived build quality is good too and, in top-spec guise, the Chery excels with good “standard feature value” with nice-to-haves such as an enlarged (10.25-inch) touchscreen infotainment system, a wireless charging pad, electrically adjustable seats and a sunroof. Note, however, that the top-spec Tiggo is notably pricier than the top-of-the-range Exter.
Moving inside the Magnite, it’s clear that Nissan is targeting a more youthful clientele with its colourful, retro-style instrument cluster and angular air vents. The cabin materials represent a mixed bag with some poor-quality finishes and average perceived build quality. In Acenta Plus guise, the Magnite does have a long list of standard features, however. The infotainment system is easy to navigate and a 360-degree camera system is a bonus. Note that the Magnite lags behind its rivals with dual airbags versus the 6 airbags in both the Exter and Tiggo 4 Pro, which might be a drawback if safety is a priority for you.
Dimensions and Practicality
| Hyundai Exter | Chery Tiggo 4 Pro | Nissan Magnite | |
| Length | 3 815 mm | 4 318 mm | 3 994 mm |
| Width | 1 710 mm | 1 831 mm | 1 758 mm |
| Height | 1 631 mm | 1 662 mm | 1 572 mm |
| Wheelbase | 2 450 mm | 2 610 mm | 2 500 mm |
| Kerb Weight | 957 kg | 1 364 kg | 1 014 kg |
| Ground Clearance | 185 mm | 180 mm | 205 mm |
| Load Capacity | 290 – 1 275 L | 340 – 1 100 L | 336 L |
Practicality Summary
The Exter has a smaller overall footprint than the Tiggo 4 Pro and is marginally smaller than the Magnite. Nonetheless, the Hyundai’s cabin is surprisingly spacious, even if its load bay is smaller than those of the Chery and Nissan. Based on manufacturer-supplied figures, when the Exter’s rear bench is folded down, it frees up more utility space than you’d get in a Tiggo 4 Pro (in the same configuration), so check that on a test drive! In terms of overall passenger space, the Chery is best, thanks to its longer wheelbase.
Pricing and warranty
Pricing is accurate as of October 2024.
| Hyundai Exter | Price | Chery Tiggo 4 Pro | Price | Nissan Magnite | Price | |
| Entry | Exter 1.2 Premium Manual | R269 900 | Tiggo 4 Pro 1.5 LiT manual | R279 900 | Magnite 1.0 Visia manual | R240 000 |
| Exter 1.2 Premium Auto | R294 900 | Tiggo 4 Pro 1.5 LiT auto | R314 900 | Magnite 1.0 Visia auto | R256 800 | |
| Tiggo 4 Pro 1.5T LiT auto | R359 900 | Magnite 1.0 Turbo Visia manual | R302 800 | |||
| Mid | Exter 1.2 Executive Manual | R289 900 | – | Magnite 1.0 Acenta manual | R260 900 | |
| Exter 1.2 Executive Auto | R314 900 | – | Magnite 1.0 Acenta auto | R277 800 | ||
| Magnite 1.0 Turbo Acenta manual | R323 100 | |||||
| Nissan Magnite 1.0 Turbo Acenta Kuro manual | R333 600 | |||||
| Magnite 1.0 Turbo Acenta auto | R353 200 | |||||
| Magnite 1.0 Turbo Acenta Kuro auto | R363 100 | |||||
| Top | Exter 1.2 Elite auto | R334 900 | Tiggo 4 Pro 1.5T Elite CVT | R386 900 | Magnite 1.0 Acenta Plus manual | R277 000 |
| Tiggo 4 Pro 1.5T LiT Elite DCT | R415 900 | Magnite 1.0 Acenta Plus auto | R294 700 | |||
| Magnite 1.0 Turbo Acenta Plus manual | R343 200 | |||||
| Magnite 1.0 Turbo Acenta Plus auto | R377 800 | |||||
| Warranty | 5-yr / 150 000 km (vehicle) 7-yr/ 200 000 km (drivetrain) | 5-yr / 150 000 km (vehicle) 10-yr / 1 million km (1st owner- engine) | 6-yr / 150 000 km | |||
| Service Plan | 3-year / 45 000 km | 5-yr / 60 000 km | 3-yr / 30 000 km |
*Note that this pricing comparison excludes the new Chery Tiggo 4 Pro Panel Van commercial vehicle.
Not sure what you’re able to afford? Let our Car Affordability Calculator help you!
Use our Finance Calculator to work out monthly premiums!
Verdict
As highlighted above, Hyundai’s newcomer competes at the lower end of the budget crossover segment and, based on our video review of the Exter, we can comfortably recommend the Indian-built model to budget-conscious buyers looking for a capable and well-priced urban runabout.
The Exter represents a stronger buying proposition than the equivalent Nissan Magnite, both in terms of engine performance and overall quality, despite the Nissan having a slightly stronger vehicle warranty.
The Chery Tiggo 4 Pro is a larger vehicle and with a strong standard feature set, it’s a difficult-to-ignore option in this segment – it’s no surprise that it’s currently a best-seller in the new-vehicle market. The top-spec Elite derivatives are the sweet spot in the range, but they do command a higher premium than the range-topping Exter and will only be accessible to buyers who can stretch their budgets accordingly.
At the time of writing, Mahindra launched its XUV 3XO budget crossover and our first encounter with the product was very positive. The XUV 3XO appears to be a well-engineered car that has a punchy 1.2-litre turbopetrol engine and comes packed with standard features. Given its keen pricing structure, it’s a strong rival to the Hyundai Exter. Look out for a comparison featuring the Mahindra 3XO soon!
If you’re looking for an affordable compact SUV for under R300k, we suggest that you put the Hyundai Exter, Chery Tiggo 4 Pro and Mahindra 3XO on your shortlist.
Buy a new Hyundai Exter on Cars.co.za / Buy a used Hyundai Exter on Cars.co.za
Buy a new Chery Tiggo 4 Pro on Cars.co.za / Buy a used Chery Tiggo 4 Pro on Cars.co.za
Buy a new Nissan Magnite on Cars.co.za / Buy a used Nissan Magnite on Cars.co.za
Related Content
What to Buy: Suzuki Fronx vs Chery Tiggo 4 Pro vs Nissan Magnite
What To Buy: Honda Elevate vs Toyota Urban Cruiser vs Chery Tiggo 4 Pro
Toyota Starlet Cross vs Suzuki Fronx: What’s the Difference?