Top 5 Small Automatic Cars
Combining efficiency, style and comfort with a reasonably affordable pricetag is no easy task, but increasingly what South Africa’s nine-to-fivers are looking for. Which compact automatic cars should you consider first?
Given the fact that an increasingly large segment of our population spend a great many hours every week stuck in traffic, the rise in popularity of compact automatic cars is easy to understand. These days the old arguments against small automatic cars (fuel economy, poor performance) have also largely been addressed by the efficiency of modern drivetrains.
In compiling this list of our five best compact automatics, we stuck to cars priced at under R400 000.
Hyundai Grand i10 Premium Automatic
The Hyundai Grand i10 is surprisingly classy inside given its pricing
Hyundai’s Grand i10 model is quietly doing brisk sales in the local market, and the automatic derivative has done well in South Africa, too.
Priced at below R269 900, the showroom appeal is strong, because the Grand i10 is not only a stylish product from the outside, but also inside, where the overall design and finish wouldn’t look out of place on a more expensive car.
Given its compact exterior it is also impressively spacious, and as we’ve come to expect from Hyundai, the features list is comprehensive. A radio/CD system with Bluetooth support and Aux and USB inputs is standard, as are air-conditioning, electric windows, two airbags and ABS. Best of all, you get a long warranty (five years/150 000 km). An extension of two years/50 000 km applies to the powertrain. This compensates to a very large extent for the lack of a standard service plan.
To drive, the 61 kW, Grand i10 provides no fireworks, but is nippy and refined enough for the daily drive. The fuel consumption figure of 6.1 L/100 km is decent. Weirdly, for a small automatic transmission car, this i10 doesn’t offer cruise control, but Hyundai’s i10 Executive 5-speed manual, does.
What is not so great about the Grand i10, is its safety spec. In recent tests, these small Hyundais scored very poorly, which is troubling and something to be aware of.
Browse Cars.co.za for a new Hyundai Grand i10
Toyota Starlet 1.5 XR Auto
Suzuki small-car know how. With the back-up of Toyota’s huge South African dealer presence.
Toyota’s version of the popular Suzuki Baleno. A value champion for South African buyers who know that a 5-door hatchback still makes more sense for most driving, compared to a crossover.
Backed by Toyota’s immense dealer network and aftersales service reputation, is it one of the most sensible small automatic cars you can buy.
Engine is a 1.5-litre petrol, which isn’t amazing at altitude. But with 77 kW, 138 Nm, and a reasonably lightweight body, Starlet offers reasonable performance. Most importantly, claimed fuel consumption is only 5.7 L/100km.
Build quality is what you’d expect from Toyota, but equipment levels aren’t overly generous for the price. You pay R327 600 for halogen headlights…
The Starlet auto uses an old-school 4-speed transmission, which is okay in slow speed traffic crawling and urban driving, but an extra gear wouldn’t go amiss for highway cruising economy or overtaking performance.
Browse Cars.co.za for a new Starlet XR
Mazda2 1.5 Dynamic Automatic
The Mazda2 is a stylish with excellent build quality.
If you’re looking for a relatively affordable automatic hatchback that also boasts some pizazz, then look no further than Mazda’s delightful “2”. This particular derivative makes use of the brand’s 1.5-litre petrol engine which delivers 85 kW, but you do lose a lot of that power at Gauteng altitudes.
The slick six-speed automatic transmission is smooth and responsive. And while the 5.7 L/100 km claimed consumption figure isn’t the lowest in this category, it appears to be more realistic than the lower claims of some turbocharged rivals.
For your money (R371 300) you get a vehicle with excellent interior quality, a dash of design flair and nimble road manners. What you don’t get is a lot of space. It has comparatively little rear legroom compared with its segment rivals, but the boot is of a decent size.
Frustratingly, Mazda doesn’t allow you to use touchscreen functionality in their cars, when driving – like every other car in class. So it’s all a bit old-school regarding this Mazda’s infotainment system, using a physical controller, when you aren’t parked.
This model is backed with Mazda’s usual three-years/100 000 km warranty and three-years/unlimited km service plan.
Search for your new Mazda2 on Cars.co.za
Suzuki Swift 1.2 GL+ Auto
The Swift is highly rated by owners and offers excellent value for money.
We’ve sung the praise of Suzuki’s Swift many times before, and we’re doing so again here. Priced at only R267 900, the 1.2 GL+ Auto offers excellent value for money. And it comes with a comprehensive specification list, that’s better than a Polo Vivo.
The latest Suzuki Swift has standard front, side and curtain airbags, ABS, ESP, and a great touchscreen infotainment system. It’s a lot of kit compared to some rivals (like Vivo), and builds on the reputation of Suzuki’s Swift in the local market.
If there is a caveat, it concerns the performance, specially at altitude. Swift’s 1.2-litre 3-cylinder is only rated at 60 kW. The CVT transmission is very efficient, with low friction to optimize urban driving fuel consumption. But CVTs can cost more to maintain in the long-term, compared to a manual or traditional automatic transmission.
Search for a Suzuki Swift on Cars.co.za
VW Polo Vivo Life Tiptronic
Want a popular compact automatic… then look no further than VW’s Polo Vivo.
One of South Africa’s most popular vehicles and with proven mechanical components, if not always the latest design and technology.
Powered by the venerable VW 1.6-litre naturally-aspirated petrol engine, this Polo Vivo makes more power than an equivalent Suzuki Swift.
With 77 kW and the 6-speed Tiptronic automatic transmission, the two-pedal Polo Vivo has a tidy power- and drivetrain. It responds well to throttle demands in traffic, and when you need to overtake slower traffic on the highway. Claimed fuel consumption is 6.5 L/100km.
Equipment levels aren’t amazing at the price of R326 600. You need to pay extra for side airbags, a reverse camera and parking sensors, which are standard on most rivals. And the driver’s footrest is awfully shaped and undersized, if you wear anything larger than a size 10 shoe.
Interestingly, the Polo Vivo auto has a 15mm suspension lift, compared to other models, which should make it a touch less vulnerable to underbody damage when driving on rough rural dirt roads.