Renault Megane 1,4 TCe Dynamique (2011) Driving Impression
You have to feel for Renault. This brand is certainly not afraid to try new things to lure people out of their Volkswagens and Toyotas. Take the second-generation Renault Megane as an example. Featuring a near-vertical rear window and a shapely derriere, it was certainly a very adventurous design. But it was always going to be somewhat bizarre, seeing as it was born under the watchful eye of designer Patrick Le Quement, a man who also brought us the downright loony Avantime and awkward Vel Satis models. Unfortunately for Renault, however, it would appear that consumers shopping in the C-segment are really rather conservative. They want subtlety, and peace of mind. And because, in addition to weirdo looks, the previous Meganes electronics were prone to melt-down, it could offer neither.
So, for the new-generation Renault Megane, reviewed here, Renault has been far more cautious. The flamboyant Le Quement is now retired and there is evidence of this in the styling of the new Megane, which is rather bland, if not unattractive. Has Renault over-reacted to criticism of the previous model? Perhaps
but then again conservatism has not exactly stopped the Volkswagen Golf from being a smash-hit sales success, again and again. More importantly, does the new Renault Megane pull off the upmarket, classy and quality impression the previous model could not?
The Renault Megane cabin
Swing open the solid-feeling drivers door, and first impressions are good. The sweeping facia is largely covered with soft-touch plastics. A metallic swish stretches the width of the dashboard and adds some welcome contrast. Fit and finish seem of a very high standard and there are no quirky design highlights, such as the previous models aircraft throttle-style handbrake. It is also immediately obvious that this Dynamique model boasts a very high standard specification level. Theres a full-colour navigation screen on top of the facia, as well as dual-zone climate control and automatic headlights and wipers. Featuring a height-adjustable drivers seat as well as a steering wheel that can adjust for rake and reach, finding a comfortable driving position in the Renault Megane is a straightforward task. Once seated, the driver is faced with a very slick looking digital speedometer. Finally, and very crucially, all the controls work with an almost Germanic feeling of solidity and refinement. So far, so good
The Renault Megane rides on one of the longest wheelbases in its segment, but somehow the packaging has not quite worked. The boot is certainly decently sized (and includes a full-size spare wheel), but rear legroom is among the tightest in this segment. Headroom is also quite restricted for taller folk. Up front there are no such qualms, but its also not perfect the control interface for the TomTom navigation system can be confusing at times. Familiarity, of course, should eliminate this.
On the road
This Megane is powered by Renaults advanced 1,4-litre turbocharged petrol engine that delivers 96 kW and 190 Nm of torque. Renault promises excellent performance coupled with good fuel economy. They didnt lie. The Renault Megane is a brisk performer, with a 0-100 km/h time of below 10 seconds. Just as impressive is its mid-range punch. Theres always sufficient grunt to overtake. And while youll struggle to match the claimed fuel economy figure of 6,6 litres/100 km, a real-world figure of around 8 litres/100 km is not to be sniffed at. If theres one gripe to be levelled at the drivetrain, it would somewhat predictably be the transmission. In typical Renault style, shifts are somewhat clunky and slow.
Although the Renault Megane rides on 16-inch alloy wheels and makes use of a torsion beam rear suspension (Golf uses more sophisticated multi-link), it generally offers good ride quality. Only on rippled road surfaces does it loose some composure. Renault says it paid a lot of attention to NVH (noise, vibration and harshness) with this car. It shows
the Meganes cabin is a quiet place wind, road and mechanical noises are well suppressed. The emphasis on comfort and refinement does, however, have a downside. The steering is light and lacks any meaningful feedback, and theres plenty bodyroll in the corners. Not a hatch for enthusiastic drivers, then
Renault Megane – Verdict
The Renault Megane has grown up. The benefits are obvious it is more refined, more comfortable and makes more of a lasting quality impression than its predecessor. But there are downsides, too. It has become somewhat of a bland car; one that does little wrong, but one which also does not excel in any particular area. Yes, it is better equipped than its rivals, but the basics of what lies underneath are no better than what youll find in a Golf. Or an Astra, a Hyundai i30, Ford Focus, Mazda3 etc
As such, the Renault Megane is somewhat of an also-ran in this segment. Pity.
We like:
- Boot space
- Long warranty/service plan
- Trim quality
- Standard features
We dont like:
- Rear legroom
- Resale value
- Ergonomics
Fast facts
Engine: 1,4-litre, four-cylinder, turbopetrol
Power: 96 kW @ 5 500 rpm
Torque: 190 N.m @ 2 250 rpm
Transmission: Six-speed manual
Wheels: 16-inch alloy
Top speed: 200 km/h
0-100 km/h: 9,7 seconds
Fuel economy: 6,6 litres/100 km
Source: www.um.co.za
Also consider:
- Volkswagen Golf (6) 1,4 TSI Comfortline: In Comfortline trim the Golf doesnt quite match the Renaults standard specification (it lacks navigation, for example), but it is soundly beats the Renault Megane in just about every other area, offering superior refinement, quality and trade-in value.
- Opel Astra 1,4T Enjoy: A really smart competitor, and quite similar to the Renault Megane in overall profile, but the German car is more economical, packs more power and also strikes a better balance between comfort and driving enjoyment.
- Fiat Bravo 1,4 T-Jet Sport: If youre looking for something a bit different, dont ignore this Fiat, one of the brands best products in a long time. Very attractive styling is not its only plus. The cabin is neat and quality is good. With 110 kW under the bonnet, its also sporty to drive. Criminally overlooked