For business, not pleasure: App-tap small sedans
From rentals and rep cars to ride-hailers: these are the app-tap small sedans that you can find among our used car listings. They may not be glamorous – or particularly sophisticated – cars, but they offer great value for those who appreciate their utility.
Whatever you may think of the 21st century – and amazingly (or depressingly, if you’re imminently headed for the old-age home), a full quarter of it would have lapsed by next year – some of the most consequential advances humanity has ever seen, are unfolding before our eyes in the new millennium.
From smartphones to social media and machine learning, technology is evolving faster than culture can keep up with. And inevitably, each successive wave of new products that either triggers or responds to changes in consumer habits, leads to mainstream products of yesteryear being eclipsed and sidelined.
The prospective demise of the internal combustion engine (ICE) was predicted most prominently in the 1970s in the wake of the 1973 Oil Crisis. But, with the prosperous Eighties then just around the corner; and coupled with an absence of cleaner, cheaper and then-viable alternatives, fossil fuels got a stay of execution that lasted well into the 2010s.
Less fortunate in its transition towards the future has been the staple silhouette of 20th-century family transport: the 3-box sedan.
It’s called a “3-box” because the engine, cabin and luggage areas are separated in a production-friendly and aesthetically balanced configuration. Yet this once-iconic automotive blueprint is now on life support due to the rampant usurpation of private transport by crossovers and SUVs, which gathered momentum in Mzansi in the 2010s. Sedans were fashionable family fare yesterday, but are fringe offerings today.
However, it’s not just the SUV revolution that’s relegated sedans away from automotive catwalks and into the proverbial slums. For every one of the precious few Mercedes-Benz S-Class or BMW 7 Series still being sold, remnants of the genre lurk at the opposite side of the scale as usually-cheap, sometimes-nasty – affordable re-imaginings built in China or India that prioritise functionality over frills; they seem lightyears removed from their forebears, which embodied European or Japanese engineering prowess.
Due to their perceived value and concessionary approach to luxury and safety specifications (driven by their low production costs and, therefore, price points), contemporary small sedans have largely moved out of the suburbs and into the realm of tendered services such as the ride-hailing and rental categories.
A deep dive into the segment reveals the sweet spot for these tiny-tyred, 4-door, front-driven, naturally-aspirated (save for the new-ish Volkswagen Polo 1.0 TSI) and usually manual-shift sedans with large, separate rear load areas (boots) is somewhere between R320 000 and R340 000. Automatic versions are available, but generally – and unattractively – far beyond the upper limit of this price bracket.
While not SA’s cheapest new car (that honour goes to the gawky R179k Suzuki S-Presso hatch), the Proton Saga with its 420-litre-sized boot can be had from R210 000. For that money, you get a 1.3-litre engine pushing 70 kW/120 Nm and elementary luxury and safety provisions, of which a USB port and Bluetooth are the most important to the ride-hailing driver (the aircon, less so) or on-the-road sales rep.
The ironically-dubbed Honda Amaze (66 kW/110 Nm) matches the Proton for boot space, though falling somewhat short of the now-discontinued Toyota Etios’ frankly astonishing 562-litre luggage capacity.
Elsewhere in the Honda stable, the Ballade with its rev-happy 1.5-litre engine (89 kW at 6 600 rpm) is arguably the most entertaining to drive in the segment. Pre-2024 facelift models provide better value.
Notable recent departures from the market include the Ford Figo sedan (445 litres) and the BAIC D20 (450 litres), but the most prominent fleet favourite to say “sayonara” was the Nissan Almera in 2023.
See also: Ford Figo (2015-2022) Buyer’s Guide
With one of the most capacious rear passenger arrangements this side of an Emirates business class seat and an exterior rear three-quarter view as hideous as the face of a proboscis monkey (not to be too unkind to the homely simian), the Almera has been a popular sight at local tourist hotspots for a decade.
See also: Nissan Almera (2013-2023) Buyer’s Guide
The axing of the Almera (and the Sentra in 2017, which incidentally did not sell a single unit until it was discontinued in May of that year), has left open the door for other less-considered candidates such as the Kia Pegas, Fiat Tipo and recently introduced Hyundai Grand i10 sedan to fill its void.
Engine-wise the Hyundai’s 1.2-litre (61 kW/113 Nm) provides almost identical outputs to Suzuki’s pint-sized, self-jesting Dzire, although the latter’s flagship undercuts its Grand i10 counterpart by R62k.
Suzuki’s larger, unpronounceable Ciaz with a 510-litre boot capacity offers a more powerful 1.5-litre 4-cylinder engine that delivers 77 kW/138 Nm, but only starts from R279k and ranges up to R339k.
Watch Ciro De Siena’s extended review of a 2017 Suzuki Ciaz:
Without a doubt, such a conducive engine capacity/price/boot space ratio explains why the Suzuki Ciaz is a common ride-hailing hit.
Disappointed at the absence of your favourite Japanese or German brand? Not to worry, for Volkswagen sells the Indian-built Virtus as the Polo Sedan here, with a choice of a 1.0-litre, triple-cylinder from R421 000 (85 kW/178 Nm) paired with a cost-saving non-DSG automatic; or a marginally less Virtuous and unboosted 1.6-litre 81 kW/152 Nm petrol engine, solely available in manual guise (from R360 500).
The 10-year-old Toyota Quest, another redoubtable ride-hailer, initially launched with a 90 kW/154 Nm 1.6-litre 4-cylinder petrol engine, mated with either a 6-speed manual- or 4-speed automatic ‘box.
See also: Toyota Corolla Quest (2014-2020) Buyer’s Guide
The 2nd iteration of the Corolla Quest, based on the 11th-gen model, debuted in 2020. It, um, sports a larger (1.8-litre) engine with peak outputs of 103 kW/173 Nm and plays in the R336k-R415k league.
In 2014 a new, entry-level VW Tiguan with 90 kW from a 1.4-litre turbopetrol engine cost just over R318 000. Today, for the same money we have to accept the developing world’s interpretations, and decade-old rehashes, of once-glamourous 3-box sedans with compromised comfort and safety specs.
As inflation- and exchange-rate-wrestling salaries battle to keep up with the cost of living, we’re getting poorer year by year and our money buys “a lot less new car” than it used to. As unfashionable as small sedans are, they still get you to your destination and, if you put them to work, they can pay their way.
Handsome is as handsome does
And that is precisely why app-tap small sedans excel so much as shared transport in what’s effectively their 2nd life, which – when I last checked – had become a 21st-century phenomenon in and of itself.
Find exclusive car-themed merchandise at the SentiMETAL Shop
Related content:
Want a versatile, spacious 7-seater? Don’t buy an SUV
Turbodiesel heroes you might have forgotten about
BMW X5: Most influential car of this century (so far)
Forget the M3 Touring, you want a Golf R Wagon