Audi A5 Sedan Review: Better than a 3 Series & C-Class?
David Taylor gets behind the wheel of the Audi A5 Sedan to unpack the model’s driving dynamics, revolutionary interior tech, and – crucially – where it sits in the pecking order against the venerable BMW 3 Series and Mercedes-Benz C-Class.
With the premium sedan segment seeing sales volumes dwindle in favour of SUVs, the remaining players must deliver something exceptional to capture buyers’ attention. Audi South Africa recently launched an all-new business-class sedan, now branded the A5, to reset the benchmark against its fellow Teutons. In this video review, David Taylor puts the flagship Black Edition TFSI quattro S tronic through its paces.
Segment Positioning and Local Lineup
The new Audi A5 Sedan replaces the previous A4, A5 Coupe, and A5 Sportback, consolidating them into a single, cohesive offering. The model is underpinned by the new PBC (Premium Platform Combustion) architecture, designed to integrate the latest tech and electrification, while enhancing driving dynamics.
The Audi A5 Sedan enters a segment that includes models such as the Alfa Romeo Giulia, BMW 3 Series, and 4 Series Gran Coupe, as well as the Mercedes-Benz C-Class.
Now that notable segment rivals – such as the Lexus IS and Jaguar XE – have faded, the battle for the business-class sedan crown remains almost exclusively, and effectively (sorry, Alfa Romeo) German.
Audi South Africa has launched a 4-derivative lineup, offering 2 distinct powertrain choices:
- Entry-Level FWD: A 2.0-litre 4-cylinder turbopetrol engine producing 146 kW and 340 Nm, paired with a 7-speed dual-clutch automatic transmission.
- Quattro Flagship (tested here): A 2.0-litre 4-cylinder turbopetrol engine delivering 200 kW and 400 Nm, featuring the Ingolstadt-based brand’s quattro all-wheel-drive system.
Audi A5 Sedan: Performance & Dynamics
The 200 kW Black Edition TFSI quattro S tronic delivers a level of straight-line performance befitting a “just below the S5” variant. When David engaged the launch control system – a straightforward process – the Audi achieved a 0–100 kph time of 6.17 seconds (almost matching the 5.9-second claimed time).
Overtaking acceleration feels suitably plentiful, but without being particularly thrilling – the Audi doesn’t generate the (albeit digitally enhanced) exhaust crackles or urgent engine note that some of its rivals do.
When made to corner enthusiastically, the Audi A5 Sedan provides excellent traction courtesy of its quattro setup. However, David notes that the suspension setup – even with standard adaptive damping – is surprisingly firm, especially on the test car, which was fitted with optional 20-inch alloy wheels.
The ride quality, while competent on smooth freeways, is uneasy over less-than-perfect road surfaces.
In terms of efficiency, the high-output engine’s real-world fuel economy settled at 9.5 L/100 km after a day of testing, against Audi’s claim of 8.1 L/100 km. This consumption, while fair for the power output, leaves room for a more economical turbodiesel engine option, which is not offered in the local lineup.
The Audi A5’s Revolutionary Interior
The cabin of the A5 Sedan is arguably its biggest talking point and represents a significant departure from older-gen Audi cabins. The highly customisable digital instrument cluster (previously known as Virtual Cockpit) blends into a large, curved central screen that uses an Android-based software system.
Audi’s design team has focused on a minimalist aesthetic (including a simplified transmission switch on the sedan’s centre console) and clean design lines. The infotainment system (specced up in the test unit to include a front-passenger display) is compatible with wireless Android Auto and Apple CarPlay.
Despite the refreshing simplicity of the screen design, some ergonomic changes may take time for owners to master:
- Climate Controls: There are no dedicated physical buttons; controls are accessed via a permanent fixed button at the bottom of the touchscreen.
- Lighting Controls: Functions typically found by the driver’s knee are now integrated into the door panel, operated by haptic feedback.
David also highlights a visible materials decision that impacts the high-end feel: the use of gloss black plastic trim around the centre console, which is prone to showing fingerprints and scratches.
Audi A5 Sedan: Practicality & Pricey Options
Thanks to the new platform, the new Audi A5 Sedan is 67 mm longer than its predecessor, providing a critical increase in wheelbase that translates directly to improved interior space.
The rear bench, however, received mixed reviews. While legroom is adequate due to the cleverly sculpted front seatbacks, headroom is compromised for taller adults, pushing the car toward a 2+2 seating configuration rather than a comfortable 5-seater.
The A5’s boot capacity, although marginally smaller than its rivals by claimed litreage, benefits significantly from its Sportback-esque liftgate design. The large opening greatly enhances practicality, successfully swallowing a respectable number of cooler boxes during the test.
How much is the new Audi A5 Sedan in South Africa?
| Model | Engine | Power | Price (ZAR) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Audi A5 S line TFSI S tronic | 2.0L Turbo | 146 kW | R1 123 000 |
| Audi A5 Black Edition TFSI S tronic | 2.0L Turbo | 146 kW | R1 166 800 |
| Audi A5 S line TFSI quattro S tronic | 2.0L Turbo | 200 kW | R1 238 000 |
| Audi A5 Black Edition TFSI quattro S tronic | 2.0L Turbo | 200 kW | R1 281 800 |
Prices (correct in November 2025) include Audi’s 1-year/unlimited kilometre warranty and a 5-year/100 000 km maintenance plan.
Audi A5 Sedan (2025) Price & Specs
Find a new/used Audi A5 for sale on Cars.co.za
Some dealerships regularly offer great deals. See our New Car Specials!
Looking to sell your car? Sell it on Cars.co.za for free
The review car, though the standard price starts at R1 281 800 (November 2025), was specced with over R310k in options, which pushed its asking price to R1 592 000. Noteworthy optional features include:
- A panoramic glass roof that can instantly change its opacity (R38k).
- The Bang & Olufsen 3D Premium Audio System (R27k).
- The Tech Pro Package (R100k), which includes the digital OLED lights and front passenger display.
Summary
The Audi A5 Sedan makes a clear statement with its class-leading interior and wealth of innovative tech. However, its general ride quality is decidedly firm, and its lofty price tag makes it the most expensive proposition in its segment compared with similarly specified rivals, which erodes its value proposition.
Does the Audi’s superior cabin benchmark outweigh the dynamic thrills and badge appeal offered by its closest rivals? If you, unlike most new-car buyers, haven’t yet set your sights on an SUV, watch David Taylor’s video review to find out where the Audi A5 Sedan lands in the business-class sedan hierarchy.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q: What is the 0–100 kph acceleration time for the Audi A5 Black Edition TFSI quattro S tronic?
A: The flagship 200 kW model achieved a 0–100 kph time of 6.17 seconds in testing, which is close to the 5.9-second claimed time.
Q: What distinguishes the Audi A5 Sedan’s interior design?
A: The cabin features a significant departure from older Audi cabins, centered on a large, curved central screen with an Android-based software system and a highly customisable digital instrument cluster.
Q: What is noted about the Audi A5 Sedan’s ride quality?
A: The suspension setup is surprisingly firm, even with standard adaptive damping, especially when fitted with optional 20-inch alloy wheels, making the ride uneasy on poor road surfaces.