Ferrari 550 Barchetta vs 812 GTS: Classic Comparison
We drive a contemporary Ferrari 812 GTS and a modern classic (and quite rare) 550 Barchetta. They represent different eras of the Maranello-based brand’s front-engined V12 roadster, but can any parallels be drawn between these 2 machines?
Standing in the pits at Zwartkops Raceway outside Pretoria, while looking at these 2 magnificent V12 roadsters, I have to get a small bugbear off my chest. As a company, Ferrari hardly needs to promote its cars – they sort of “sell themselves”; not much in the way of conventional marketing is required, I’d say.
However, the storied brand does sometimes take liberties, particularly in its press releases, to ramp up the desirability of its products. A release (dated 9 September 2019) for the 812 GTS states: “Exactly 50 years on from the debut of the last spider in the Ferrari range to sport a front-mounted V12, the 812 GTS hails a triumphant return for a model type that has played a pivotal role in the marque’s history…”
It carries on: “The last in that long lineage was the 1969 365 GTS4, also known as the Daytona Spider…” It is at this stage where you might start to rub your chin, as you glance at the shapely 550 Barchetta…
But wait, Ferrari then continues with: “The front-mounted V12 architecture has not been used in a Ferrari series-production spider since the 365 GTS4.” That said, four special series limited editions have been launched: the 550 Barchetta Pininfarina in 2000, the Superamerica in 2005, the SA Aperta in 2010 and, most recently, the F60 America of which just 10 were built…
So, if you split standard series production and limited editions, this is indeed the 1st time such a model has been made available for 50 years. Clearly, one can spin virtually anything any which way you fancy!
Modern siblings
Getting these 2 open-top V12s together was no small feat. The owners of these machines both live in Johannesburg, but our first attempt to get these cars side-by-side (in 2022) coincided with the owner of the 812 GTS taking delivery of the car – so, not the ideal moment to ask him to hand me the keys, then. A few months later, all was planned – including an empty track just for us – and then the rain came. But it was a case of 3rd time lucky – on a sunny autumn day it all worked out at Zwartkops Raceway.
A 2-decade advancement in Ferrari’s design language is immediately evident with these cars. The Ferrari 550 Barchetta has a very strong, detailed design, which it shares with the 550 Maranello, but the fact that it is essentially a permanent roadster makes it rather attractive. A cloth roof can be installed, but this takes rather a lot of time and effort. Even so, the owner admits that he loves the fact that the car is compromised and a full-blown roadster and that you must pick your days carefully to enjoy the car.
Both have the rear humps behind the occupants’ heads, while the Barchetta allows for a cleaner and more unobstructed design than the GTS since only the top part of the roof is stored behind the cabin.
Neither of these cars are garage queens, as both owners have set out to enjoy their V12s as often as possible. This example of the Ferrari 550 Barchetta has close to 49 000 km on the odo – a considerable number as the owner purchased it with only around 8 800 km back in 2006 in the UK.
The owner eagerly shares his experiences with the car since that day: “In 2008, I drove from London to Monza, on to Maranello and then watched the Grand Prix at Monza. I’ve had some great memories and experiences with the car in the UK and being part of the Ferrari Owners Club GB.
“Apart from that, the car has been on Killarney International Raceway in Cape Town, Kyalami Grand Prix Circuit in Johannesburg and even Silverstone in the UK. I believe the miles on the car just add to its provenance. My next aim is 100 000 km – after all, no one checks the mileage on a 250 GTO!”
To sum it up, the fact that he did 35 laps on this track where we are standing (during a Ferrari event a few weeks before our shoot) attests to his intent to enjoy the car to the fullest! He also customised it a little by painting the rims a slightly darker colour, as well as having a yellow stripe on the bonnet (as a tribute to #4153 GT, 250 GTO) and, finally, he got Mimmo Schiattarella to build a special exhaust for him.
The owner of the 812 GTS has also had an interesting journey that led him to some of Ferrari’s most exciting, modern cars. Since he purchased his Prancing Horse, he has made full use of it.
“I visited the Ferrari factory in 2008, however, I developed a strong interest in (the brand) even before that, when Michael Schumacher was racing F1 for them. At the factory, I was impressed with the way they built the cars, the trees in the factory and the cleanliness. I never thought I would own one, though.
“Shortly after I received the car, I did 2 800 km with it on a single journey during 8 days of driving. The car’s ability to cruise on the open road comfortably really impressed me. We also tackled several back roads, as well as mountain passes,” he adds.
The track is empty and at our exclusive disposal before the sun sets and I select to first slip into the modern classic. There is a level of simplicity around the cabin that modern cars lack.
That is partly thanks to less technology being on offer at the time of manufacture – depending on your approach or need for technology, you will either appreciate or loathe it. I, for one, appreciate the lack of technology, as what is housed beneath the light-blue bonnet in front of me is of greater importance.
An interesting little fact is that the windscreen is not the same size as a standard 550 Maranello’s, but is specific (lower) to the Ferrari 550 Barchetta. That is a fact the owner was told when he bought the car, so he has been taking good care of the windscreen.
Behind the ‘wheel of the 550 Barchetta
The 4-point harness, which thankfully clips in like a normal seatbelt, has been used in several Ferraris since the Barchetta. It makes you feel much more secure than a standard seatbelt while doing away with the cumbersome machinations that a real harness, with its centre locking mechanism, requires. Needless to say, you know you are not driving an everyday Ferrari when it is equipped with one of these features.
Specifications
- Model: Ferrari 550 Barchetta
- Engine: 5.5-litre, V12, petrol
- Power: 362 kW at 7 000 rpm
- Torque: 568 N.m at 5 000 rpm
- Transmission: 6-speed manual, RWD
- Weight: 1 690 kg
- 0-100 kph: 4.4 sec (claimed)
- Top speed: 300 kph (claimed)
Setting off, I immediately realise that this is no lightweight car. After all, the Ferrari 550 Barchetta tips the scales at 1 690 kg, but even so, with 362 kW and 568 Nm on tap, there is an immediate and noticeable amount of acceleration available thanks to plentiful low-down torque – as should be the case with a GT.
However, soon I start to rev out the gears and allow the needle to swing past 7 000 rpm. It is here where the liveliness of the engine can be intimately experienced. Zwartkops is not a long track (only 2.5 km) and has a combination of mostly shorter and lower-gear corners with 1 very fast and long right-hander.
It is through the latter that the Barchetta feels especially stable, but in the tighter corners, you can truly feel the outer tyres load up – where a brief push of the throttle pedal will easily allow the rear axle to break traction. This is also helped by the fact that the rear tyres are not that wide. You can also pay attention to the weight transfer once the car has settled in a corner, or is about to settle, as that is another factor to keep in mind if you want to break traction at the rear or just keep it close to the limit.
Take into account that more than 2 decades of development have transformed performance cars dramatically; you certainly need less skill to play with the Ferrari 550 Barchetta than I expected.
Having taken the Barchetta to numerous track days, the owner can easily drive his car on the limit most of the time, which he eagerly illustrates to me. From my drive but also during his drive, it is evident that on track you need to switch off ASR, as it inhibits your efforts to put down the power completely.
I don’t make use of all the braking force as I approach corners, but even so, the brake pedal is relatively firm and lowers the car’s speed with a good level of confidence. The steering provides decent feedback while the gears can be swapped faster than I expected.
At times you can hear the “clack” sound as the lever touches the edges of the metal open gate. Some blipping of the throttle makes the process even smoother and, after a couple of laps, I have a higher level of appreciation for the Ferrari 550 Barchetta. The track might not be its ideal environment, but the fun factor on track that it provides, together with its touring capability, makes it a very attractive proposition.
Behind the ‘wheel of the 812 GTS
If touring ability and entertaining dynamics are the aspects by which you rate a car, the 812 GTS should be up there as well. When I attended the launch of the 812 Superfast in Italy in 2017, I was enormously impressed. I’ll admit, it was my first Ferrari launch, but one must always try to stay objective.
In truth, the 812 Superfast is barely a GT – it’s more of a front/mid-engined supercar. Most of the time it was very difficult to put all that power and torque onto the Italian roads. On track, it was a different story.
Specifications
- Model: Ferrari 812 GTS
- Engine: 6.5-litre, V12, petrol
- Power: 588 kW at 8 500 rpm
- Torque: 718 N.m at 7 000 rpm
- Transmission: 7-speed, dual-clutch automatic, RWD
- Weight: 1 645 kg
- 0-100 kph: 3.0 sec (claimed)
- Top speed: 340 kph (claimed)
With the introduction of the 812 GTS, Ferrari clearly wanted to lure customers who want the best of both worlds: touring, al fresco experiences but with nearly the same level of performance.
Make no mistake, Ferrari has smartly converted the 812 Superfast into a partial convertible. The same focused intention of the coupe is still evident in its overall design, especially in the sharply designed front lights, the side air outlets and the way the shoulder lines run towards and over the rear fenders. With the roof in place, there is barely any difference compared with the 812 Superfast. But today, the roof will be lowered and stowed so we can experience the GTS in the way its engineers and designers intended.
From behind the ‘wheel, it is a pure modern Ferrari. Having driven an 812 Competizione a few weeks earlier, the cabin feels immediately welcome and snug.
As I make myself comfortable, the kind owner tells me to enjoy the car to its fullest, and it is immediately noticeable that less effort is needed to pilot this GT than the 550. The start button lets the engine burst to life, the right-hand paddle engages 1st gear and I’m off. Leave it in Auto and the Sport drive mode and it feels like you could be heading to the shops. There is a clear raspy sound to the exhaust note, never leaving you in doubt as to what is available under your right foot.
With the Manettino knob dialled to Race, I pull the left paddle a few times and, with 2nd gear selected, I accelerate down the straight. In an instant, there is a very strong and urgent mechanical push from the engine and the next moment the rev lights illuminate at the top of the steering wheel. The first few LEDs light up close to 6 000 rpm and then the row lights up progressively as you approach the red line at 9 000 rpm, before the final blue light comes on. The engine truly comes on song in the last 1 000 rpm!
I pull the lever and select 3rd gear. Moments later the brakes feel very strong and sharp. With little input through the steering wheel, the nose darts into the corner and I confidently start to press the throttle pedal again. Even more so than in the Barchetta, overpowering the rear axle is not difficult, but the 812 GTS has more electronic systems (not to mention modern tyres) that can prevent this from happening.
The speed with which the engine revs is markedly quicker than in the Barchetta. It picks up speed very quickly in a smooth, yet potent, manner. It makes the car feel lighter than what it is. Although you can leave the gearbox in its automatic setting and allow it to give you a quicker time around the track, that is not as much fun as deciding when to shift gears yourself. The barking sound from the exhaust on each down change is a true joy while the engine – and its quartet of exhaust ends – inform your passenger and anyone else in the vicinity that the powertrain (with the F140 GA engine at its core) has dropped a cog.
Racking up the corners, the car also starts to feel more compact than it is. This is attributable to the pin-sharp handling, as the car does seem to shrink around you the more you experience it on track.
Things happen quicker in the 812 GTS – the speeds you carry towards and through corners are notably higher. As expected, less input is needed to keep the car on track. Having said that, if you want to deploy the full 588 kW with the nanny systems switched off, you’ll need to be handy behind the ‘wheel.
Summary
On the highway back home, the Ferrari 550 Barchetta sits comfortably below 3 000 rpm at an indicated 120 kph – although I think it will cruise just as effortlessly at double this speed. Also keep in mind that only 448 units of this drop-top were produced, making this a semi-rare modern-classic Ferrari.
The 812 GTS will be more comfortable on longer journeys, is a less compromised package and offers its occupants all the creature comforts. Although not limited in production numbers, we can safely assume that not too many of them will be produced. So, a Ferraro 550 Barchetta or a 812 GTS? I guess one’s decision will be influenced by which other Ferraris are already in the garage…
Find a new/used Ferrari model on Cars.co.za
Find exclusive car-themed merchandise at the SentiMETAL Shop
Related content:
Naturally aspirated Ferrari 12Cilindri revs up
How many Ferraris have been sold in SA in 2023 thus far?
Ferrari F355 Challenge: Classic Drive
Ferrari F40: Enzo’s Greatest – SentiMETAL Ep13