Toyota SA boss calls out ‘disingenuous’ Global NCAP
The head of Toyota South Africa Motors has branded Global NCAP’s testing of entry-level vehicles “a little bit disingenuous”, suggesting a high star rating “is not equal to safety”…
- Toyota SA boss hits back at Global NCAP
- Corolla Cross & Starlet both recently tested
- Regulation “probably not a bad route to go”
The head of Toyota South Africa Motors (TSAM) has called out Global NCAP for being a “little bit disingenuous” in its testing of entry-level derivatives, adding that a high occupant-safety rating from the assessment programme “is not equal to safety”.
Andrew Kirby, President and CEO of Toyota SA Motors, made the comments during an intriguing interview in Cars.co.za’s custom-built podcast booth at Naamsa’s SA Auto Week 2026 gathering in Durban, KwaZulu-Natal in October.
“It’s a tricky one, because affordability is key. So, we have a model line-up and the different grades have different levels of safety equipment. We know from our research that the value-for-money proposition is really important. Typically, [with] the entry grades, people don’t necessarily want to pay for those extra airbags, as an example,” he said.
“Then [Global] NCAP comes along, tests the vehicle and says: ‘no, Toyota’s got a low NCAP rating’. That’s a little bit disingenuous, because the other grades do [have additional airbags],” Kirby told Cars.co.za.
Corolla Cross and Starlet both recently tested
For context, note that in January 2026, Global NCAP handed the Prospecton-built Corolla Cross 2 stars for adult-occupant safety, citing the “absence of standard side head [airbag] protection”. The organisation seemingly tested either a base XI or a mid-spec XS derivative (which each offer five airbags), since the XR and GR-Sport variants ship standard in SA with curtain airbags (taking their respective totals to seven).
Then, in May 2026, Global NCAP hit the SA-spec Toyota Starlet with a zero-star rating, again citing a “lack of restraint systems like side-body and side-head airbags” as a key issue. The organisation did, however, note that the entry-level version of the Starlet assessed “was equipped with only two airbags at the time of testing, while an updated version, introduced locally in September 2025, is offered with six airbags as standard across the range”.
Global NCAP says it “offered Toyota the opportunity to volunteer the six-airbag Starlet for testing” but that “the manufacturer declined”. So, Global NCAP went ahead and assessed the updated Starlet using “its own funding”, ultimately awarding the revised version four stars for adult-occupant protection in September 2026.
Shortly before that, in August 2026, the Automobile Association of South Africa (AA) – which launched the “Safer Cars For Africa” campaign in partnership with Global NCAP back in 2017 – released a statement noting government’s proposed “revision of the minimum safety standards for all new passenger cars sold locally”. The AA called for curtain-airbag protection and electronic stability control to be made mandatory.
Toyota SA boss says safety is ‘absolutely critical’
Though Kirby seemed not to be opposed to the idea of government mandating minimum safety-equipment levels for new vehicles, he cautioned that doing so would naturally result in an increase in the price of many entry-level derivatives.
“We know that if there’s regulation – which is probably not a bad route to go – it means that everybody will need to comply and it will push up the price of entry vehicles. And I’m not so sure that’s what the South African public really wants.
“On the other hand, safety is absolutely critical for us, so we’re not trying to – at all – compromise safety. [However,] NCAP is not equal to safety; it’s only a particular measurement using their particular way of defining things.
“But we have already taken the decision to expand and make sure that even our entry-level grades do achieve high NCAP ratings. We have to try to find a way of making that still attractive for customers,” he said.
Brand chief calls for level playing field
Stating that this was “only a discussion at the lower end” of the market and suggesting there was “no question about our high-end vehicles”, Kirby went on to point out that “there are hundreds of different models that also don’t comply” with Global NCAP’s suggested minimum safety standards in South Africa.
“But, of course, we’re a leading brand and, I guess, targeted in some way – which is fine [and] we completely understand that – but it is an important balance that we need to discuss. As a country, are we going to now regulate all of those requirements or not? Because we all need to be on the same playing field, right?”
After Global NCAP released the results of its Corolla Cross crash-test in January 2026, Toyota SA Motors said it was considering making curtain airbags standard across the locally built crossover line-up, though didn’t specify a targeted timeline for such action.
“The Global NCAP results coincide with an ongoing internal review of standardised curtain shield airbag fitment across the entire Corolla Cross range for the local market. This review is in line with Toyota’s global philosophy of kaizen (continuous improvement), which guides TSAM’s ongoing commitment to enhancing product safety, quality and performance throughout the Toyota Production System,” the company said at the time.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q: Why did Toyota SA’s CEO criticise Global NCAP’s vehicle safety assessments?
A: Andrew Kirby argued that testing entry-level grades without factoring in full model-range safety specs is “disingenuous”, emphasising that affordability remains critical and that a high crash-test score does not fully equate to overall real-world safety.
Q: How did Global NCAP rate the South African-built Toyota Corolla Cross and Starlet?
A: Global NCAP awarded the Corolla Cross two stars in January 2026 due to a lack of standard side-head airbags. The Starlet initially scored zero stars for its entry-level variant, though a later test of the updated six-airbag version earned a four-star rating in September 2026.
Q: What are the broader implications of mandating stricter safety regulations in South Africa?
A: While acknowledging that safety is vital and that regulation could level the playing field, Toyota warned that making features like curtain airbags mandatory would drive up prices.
Related content
Global NCAP: Starlet moves from zero to 4 stars