GWM P300 diesel or PHEV? Why the cheaper bakkie makes more sense
The GWM P300 PHEV promises impressive performance, electric-only commuting and lower fuel bills. But with a R215 000 premium over the 2.4-litre turbodiesel, does the plug-in hybrid make financial sense?
GWM has spent nearly two decades building its bakkie reputation in South Africa. While several other Chinese bakkie brands have come and gone, GWM has remained, earning credibility in a market traditionally dominated by Toyota, Ford and Isuzu.
That experience has helped GWM understand what South African bakkie buyers want. But as the brand embraces electrification, buyers face an interesting dilemma: stick with a conventional turbodiesel or spend considerably more on a plug-in hybrid?
The GWM P300 PHEV certainly offers more power and the prospect of dramatically reduced fuel consumption. However, when you consider the financial implications, the decision becomes rather more complicated.
How GWM earned its bakkie credibility
GWM was among the first Chinese manufacturers to establish a lasting presence in South Africa’s fiercely competitive bakkie market.
When several rival Chinese brands withdrew during the early 2010s, GWM persevered. Its Steed range wasn’t especially sophisticated, but the bakkies were affordable, practical and helped establish a foothold in the local market.
The arrival of the P-Series marked a significant step forward. Here was a Chinese double-cab that could compete more convincingly with established rivals in terms of comfort, equipment and refinement.
Today, with more Chinese bakkies entering South Africa, GWM is no longer the newcomer trying to prove itself. And with the arrival of the P300 PHEV, the brand is attempting to redefine what a lifestyle bakkie can offer. But is the new hybrid necessarily the better buy?
GWM P300 2.4TD: The sensible choice?
Although diesel-powered passenger vehicles are relatively uncommon in China, GWM develops powertrains for export markets where turbodiesel bakkies remain popular, including Australia, Southern Africa and South America.
One of its most important recent developments is the 2.4-litre GW4D24 turbodiesel engine, which is also used in the Tank 300.
In the P300, it produces 135 kW and 480 Nm, driving through a 9-speed automatic transmission.
Those outputs are competitive rather than class-leading. Mitsubishi’s 2.4-litre bi-turbodiesel Triton, for example, produces 150 kW, giving it an 11% power advantage over the GWM.
Still, the P300’s generous torque output should prove more than adequate for everyday driving, towing and long-distance touring.
And in LTD specification, the diesel has another advantage: it comes equipped with all-terrain tyres, a snorkel and other off-road-focused features that make it particularly appealing to adventurous buyers.
Search for a GWM P300 bakkie on Cars.co.za
Could the PHEV be cheaper to maintain?
Like the Toyota Hilux and Ford Ranger, the P300 uses a steel ladder-frame chassis designed to withstand demanding working conditions and challenging terrain.
That makes it well suited to South Africa’s extensive network of gravel roads, where payload capacity and durability remain important considerations.
However, the engine under the bonnet introduces another ownership consideration.
Modern common-rail turbodiesels rely on sophisticated, high-pressure fuel-injection systems. Although good-quality diesel is widely available in South Africa, fuel contamination can be a concern, particularly at remote filling stations where storage and maintenance standards may vary.
Water or other contaminants in diesel can damage injectors and fuel-system components, potentially resulting in expensive repairs.
The PHEV’s turbocharged petrol engine avoids diesel-specific fuel-system and emissions concerns. However, that doesn’t automatically make it cheaper to maintain.
Its additional electric motor, high-voltage battery and associated electronics introduce complexity of their own. Without long-term reliability data, it would be premature to declare either powertrain the more durable option.
Why stop-start traffic favours the PHEV
One of the strongest arguments against using a modern turbodiesel bakkie primarily as a family runabout is the effect of repeated short journeys and prolonged stop-start traffic.
Diesel engines generally perform more efficiently once they’ve reached their normal operating temperature. Frequent short trips can prevent that from happening, while also creating challenges for the diesel particulate filter (DPF), where fitted.
A DPF traps soot from the exhaust and periodically burns it off through a process known as regeneration. However, repeated short journeys at low speeds can interrupt this process, potentially leading to DPF-related problems.
For owners who spend much of their time crawling through Gauteng or Cape Town traffic, this is worth considering.
The P300 PHEV offers a very different experience. Its 33.1 kWh battery provides a claimed electric-only range of up to 115 km on the NEDC cycle. With sufficient charge, many owners could complete their daily commute without using the petrol engine at all.
The benefits extend beyond fuel savings. Electric propulsion delivers smooth, quiet acceleration and eliminates engine idling during EV-only operation. Of course, that advantage depends heavily on charging habits. Owners who rarely plug in will miss much of what makes the PHEV appealing.
Search for a GWM P300 bakkie on Cars.co.za
GWM P300 PHEV vs diesel: The R215k question
Here’s where the comparison becomes particularly interesting.
The GWM P300 2.4TD LTD 4×4 costs R699 900, while the P300 2.0T Pioneer Hi4-T PHEV is priced at R914 900.
That’s a substantial R215 000 difference.
The diesel offers 135 kW and 480 Nm, while the PHEV’s turbocharged petrol engine and electric motor produce combined outputs of 310 kW and 750 Nm.
The hybrid is therefore considerably more powerful, and its electric motor provides immediate throttle response. It also retains a 3 500 kg braked towing capacity, making it a genuinely versatile lifestyle bakkie.
But what about fuel consumption? The diesel’s quoted consumption figure is 8.6 L/100 km, while GWM claims just 2.4 L/100 km for the PHEV.
That sounds like an extraordinary saving. However, the PHEV’s official figure assumes a particular test cycle that includes driving on electricity supplied by an external charge.
In other words, the petrol consumption figure doesn’t account for all the energy used to propel the vehicle. Actual running costs depend on how frequently the battery is charged, the price of electricity and the proportion of driving completed in electric mode.
Can fuel savings justify the PHEV’s price?
In Cars.co.za’s review of the GWM P300 PHEV, the hybrid returned an impressive 6.0 L/100 km over a 271 km mixed-driving test route that began with a depleted battery.
That’s a commendable result for a large, powerful double-cab bakkie, and substantially better than the diesel’s quoted 8.6 L/100 km.
However, the two figures aren’t directly comparable: the diesel figure is a quoted consumption value, while the PHEV’s result was recorded during a specific real-world test.
Even if we assume the PHEV uses 2.6 litres less fuel per 100 km, the financial savings aren’t necessarily as dramatic as they first appear.
For illustration, at a petrol price of R21/litre, that 2.6-litre difference would represent a saving of R54.60 per 100 km, assuming both vehicles used fuel costing the same amount.
At that rate, recovering the R215 000 purchase premium would require almost 394 000 km.
In practice, petrol and diesel prices differ, and this simplified comparison doesn’t account for electricity consumption, charging costs or the PHEV’s ability to complete some journeys without burning petrol.
For an owner who charges regularly using surplus home solar power, the savings could be considerably greater. Someone who covers 50 km daily in electric mode, for example, could avoid a substantial amount of fuel expenditure over several years.
However, solar-generated electricity isn’t automatically free. The cost of the installation, potential foregone electricity savings elsewhere in the home and any additional grid charging should also be considered.
The important point is that there’s no universal break-even mileage for the P300 PHEV. The result depends on how the vehicle is driven, charged and financed.
Does the battery warranty change the equation?
The P300 PHEV is covered by a 7-year/200 000 km vehicle warranty, while its high-voltage battery has separate coverage of 8 years or 150 000 km, whichever comes first.
That’s reassuring for buyers planning to keep the vehicle for several years, although those who accumulate high mileages could exceed the battery warranty limit well before recovering the hybrid’s purchase premium through running-cost savings.
Importantly, the expiry of a battery warranty doesn’t mean the battery will fail. It simply means that repairs or replacement outside the warranty terms could become the owner’s responsibility.
Battery degradation, long-term repair costs and eventual resale values are additional considerations that are difficult to quantify for such a recently introduced model.
And those uncertainties matter when the purchase-price difference is R215 000.
Verdict: Which GWM P300 makes more sense?
The GWM P300 PHEV is an impressive piece of engineering. Its combination of 310 kW, 750 Nm, electric-only commuting and genuine 4×4 capability makes it one of the most interesting double-cab bakkies on the South African market.
For buyers who value performance, refinement and the ability to complete daily journeys on electricity, it offers advantages that the turbodiesel simply cannot match.
But if the decision comes down primarily to financial value, the P300 2.4TD LTD remains difficult to beat.
It’s substantially cheaper to purchase, well equipped for off-road use and offers the familiar long-distance touring characteristics of a turbodiesel.
The PHEV could make excellent sense for someone with inexpensive home charging, predictable daily journeys and a willingness to pay more for performance and technology.
For everyone else, however, the R215 000 saving at the dealership is likely to be more compelling than the promise of lower fuel bills.