Renault Grand Scenic 1.9 dCi Dynamique (2009) Driving Impression
Just as each new generation of Mercedes-Benz’s S-Class is eagerly anticipated by the motoring world, because it is virtually guaranteed to redefine its segment and set new benchmarks, much is expected of each new Renault MPV.
After all, this is the brand that created the genre, and though it has faced stiff competition these last few years, it regularly moves the game forward just as the others start to catch up. With the latest Scenic, tested here in seven-seat “Grand” guise, has Renault managed to outwit the rest again?
Swiss army knife of cars
Aesthetics play a very small role in the typical customer’s purchasing considerations, but nevertheless it is worth highlighting some of the Grand Scenic’s features. Firstly, it is offered only in top-end Dynamique trim, which means it gets smart 16-inch alloy wheels, full colour coding and neat satin silver accenting. Secondly, there are some design quirks, as is to be expected from a French car maker the rear lights are particularly striking – while the front end looks like a marriage of current Clio and new-generation Megane. You may also notice that it is significantly larger than the previous car, measuring in at 70 mm longer.
It is that last bit of information in the previous paragraph that is most important, because Renault’s designers have used the extra length (the wheelbase is also longer) to create a massively spacious cabin.
It now claims that even adults of average size can use the rearmost seats. Starting at the back, let’s try and paint a picture of the amazing versatility on offer. With all seven seats taken, the boot space is limited, as is the case with all seven seaters. Those rear seats fold flat into the floor, though, and when this is done there is a very large boot on offer. Those seated in the centre row are particularly well-catered for. There are three individual chairs, and each can slide individually over a surprisingly long distance, and also offer reclining backrests. These seats can also be removed. When this is done, the Grand Scenic is transformed into a true carry-all.
But wait, there’s more… the front passenger seat can also be folded flat, allowing for the transportation of some really long objects. As is to be expected from Renault, there are a large number of storage spaces hidden throughout the cabin. You genuinely can lose items in this vehicle for a very long time…
And the driver? Well, with such a high level of specification, including rake/reach adjustment for the steering wheel and a height-adjustable driver’s seat, there isn’t too much reason for complaint. Nevertheless, there are quirks. The almost centrally placed digital instrumentation display may look very smart and high-tech, but it’s not the easiest to read, and the same counts for the standard TomTom navigation system. The gearlever, too, is not ideally placed, requiring somewhat of a stretch to operate. But that’s about it as far as complaints go.
The build quality of the latest Renault products really impress, and like the Megane on which it is based, the Grand Scenic features a sweeping dashboard made of high-quality, soft-to-the-touch plastic, with convincing satin silver accents to add some brightness to the otherwise dark, sombre trim. Dynamique specification adds to the upmarket feel of the cabin, and brings the aforementioned satellite navigation, as well as dual-zone climate control, a powerful Arkamys sound system with Bluetooth and auxiliary support, cruise control, auto lights and wipers, rear park assist and six airbags. Also part of the comprehensive safety package is an electronic stability programme (ESP). Probably the only spec item it lacks is leather upholstery, which would be easier to clean than the fitted cloth.
Refined and frugal
Providing the motivating force is Renault’s proven 1.9-litre turbodiesel engine. It’s not a particularly high-tech engine, but it nevertheless boasts good refinement and delivers eager acceleration, especially once up and running. You may need to stir the six-speed manual transmission once in a while for steep inclines, or when overtaking, but generally speaking there’s enough power under foot. It is also impressively economical, with a consumption figure of around 7-litres/100 km being consistently on offer.
The relaxed, quiet engine contributes significantly to the overall refined character of the Grand Scenic. Cruising along, the cabin is well insulated against mechanical, road and wind noise, and the long-travel suspension comfortably (and quietly) soaks up most bumps.
In many ways the Renault Grand Scenic 1.9 dCi Dynamique reminds of the marque’s own Espace luxury MPV. It is an excellent long-distance family car, just like its bigger sibling.
Verdict
Once again Renault has moved the MPV game forward. By replicating much of what makes the larger Espace model so great, the Grand Scenic comes across as a premium product in its refinement and interior finishes.
But at its core the Grand Scenic’s biggest talent remains its startlingly flexible interior. At the price it undercuts most of its rivals, yet offers much more, in addition to a 5 year/100 000 km service plan. It’s superb.
We like:
Seating flexibility
Standard specification
Ride quality
Perceived build quality
Comfort
We don’t like:
Some ergonomic quirks
Fast facts
Engine: 1.9-litre, four-cylinder, turbodiesel
Power: 96 kW @ 3 750 rpm
Torque: 300 Nm @ 1 750 rpm
Transmission: six-speed manual
Wheels: 16-inch alloy
Top speed: 195 km/h
0-100 km/h: N/A seconds
Fuel economy: N/A litres/100 km
Also consider:
Toyota Verso 2.0D TX:
An impressive, but pricey offering from Toyota that boasts excellent refinement and comfort, as well as superb frugality. But it’s not as cleverly packaged as the Grand Scenic, and also ultimately not as spacious.
Volkswagen Touran 1.9 Trendline:
As per usual, the similarly priced offering from Volkswagen falls short on engine power and standard specification. If you really want the Touran (it’s a great vehicle), but need the extra spec and power, then you have to pay significantly more for the 2.0 Highline derivative.
Fiat Multipla 1.9 MultiJet Dynamic:
Laugh all you want but this quirky Fiat is actually a good vehicle. Offering two rows of three seats, it is ultimately not quite as practical as the Renault, but there’s huge packing space.