Porsche 911 Targa vs 911 Carrera 3.2 Targa: Classic Comparison
The 911 Targa occupies a small niche within Porsche’s line-up. Should more buyers consider this slightly quirky cabrio/coupe offering? We take a classic Carrera 3.2 Targa and the modern-day 992 Targa 4 for a coastal drive outside of beautiful Cape Town.
IMAGES: Peet Mocke
The 911 Targa is one of the rarer variants in the Zuffenhausen-based firm’s range: enthusiasts either like or dislike it, which can’t be said of the other models! Surely a Carrera S or -GT3 isn’t as polarising? However, it can also be argued that a 911 Targa derivative represents the best between what a standard Carrera coupe and a standard Carrera convertible offers. The best of both worlds, then?
In terms of the roof, the 911 Targa represents a halfway point between being a coupe and a convertible. You can still enjoy fresh-air motoring, but at the same, it is less “windy” than in a full convertible.
Porsche’s Targa history has been well documented. We’ve seen examples of the Porsche 911 Targa since the earliest of times with its soft rear window. That transformed into what can be viewed as a large sunroof in the 993-, 996- and 997-series 911s. With the arrival of the 991 and now the current 992, the beautiful U-shaped metal bar returned with a fixed rear window and a fully automatic system.
The classic: G-series 911 Carrera 3.2 Targa
The owner of this Targa has had more than 10 classic, air-cooled Porsche 911s through his garage. He now owns 3, including this Targa, which he also uses several times a week. It is a true “daily driver”.
Specifications:
- Model: Porsche 911 Carrera 3.2 Targa (G-series)
- Engine: 3.2-litre, flat-6, petrol
- Power: 152 kW at 5 900 rpm
- Torque: 264 Nm at 4 800 rpm
- Transmission: 5-speed manual
- Weight: 1 210 kg
- 0-97 kph: 6.3 seconds (claimed)
- Top Speed: ± 240 kph
Setting the alarm clock for just after 06:00, we all meet up just over an hour later next to the road outside Gordon’s Bay, around 45 km east of Cape Town. This coastal road is known as one of the most scenic routes in South Africa with a perfect ribbon of tarmac – a great place to enjoy these cars.
Thanks to its whale-tale, this red Targa looks much more purposeful than those units without it. If you prefer the more simple lines of the 911, you will undoubtedly rather select one without the large wing!
We decide to start the photography a little later and first enjoy the crisp morning air, the light traffic and the scenery. Clarence Drive is a single-lane, flowing road that hugs the coastline. However, with a rock face on the one side and a low, man-built rock wall on the other, you must keep your enthusiasm at bay behind the wheel of a car. We opt to keep the removable top on for now, which allows us to have a normal conversation in the cabin although there is certainly some more wind noise than in an equivalent coupe.
Even with more than 172 000 km on the odo, this 915-gearbox still feels good. As long as you don’t rush the gearbox (why would you, anyway?) the gears change with relative ease between the five speeds, while some gears are closer to one another in the horizontal shift action than others.
You can cruise at low engine speeds of 2 000 to 3 000 rpm, and even with light throttle inputs, there is sufficient torque to accelerate in a spirited manner. The 911 Targa feels compact and, as expected, low to the ground, just like a proper sports car should.
I drop a couple of gears and press the accelerator pedal a little harder, the revs climb quickly and, with notable haste, the rev needle swings past 5 000 and 6 000 rpm. It is during these bursts of acceleration and also during braking that I’m reminded that the Carrer 3.2 Targa only tips the scales at about 1 210 kg.
After a while, I start to feel more confident behind the ‘wheel and enjoy every moment that the free-revving engine sends the needle around the clock. When you start to push on, you do realise there is some scuttle shake, but that’s also to be expected. I almost want to say you are more aware of it in a cabriolet because the parts that indicate scuttle shake are further behind you and also stowed away.
The Carrera 3.2 Targa makes up for it, though. Lift the targa top and then fold it up. You can either store it behind the seats or place it in the luggage compartment in the front – where it is more safely stowed and movement is also more limited – depending on what else you have in this compartment, of course.
With the roof down and picking up speed past 100 kph, the wind buffeting is very limited. There is some wind noise of course, but just enough fresh air is blowing through the cabin, while the owner and I can still keep our conversation going. Approach high speeds and it starts to become more difficult.
In a straight line, but especially when the road twists and turns, the steering wheel is communicative and you can sense precisely what the front axle is up to. Fitted with the small (215/60 R15 in front and 195/65 R15 at the rear on this car) wheels and tyre combination, the 911 Targa also rides very pliantly. Turn-in is as good as you would expect, while there is limited body roll, similar to any other 911 of the era.
The owner shares some thoughts about 911s and his Targa: “I’ve had this car for the past 9 years. Ideally, I would have liked to have a coupe, a Targa and a cabriolet, but I sadly sold a very neat G50 Cabriolet a few years ago. I found the Targa to have a little more headroom than a coupe, although this matters little to me. My love for Porsche stems from my first car, which was an oval-window Volkswagen Beetle.”
The Carrera 3.2 Targa’s narrow body and small footprint elevate the experience behind the wheel even further. The upright front lights indicate where the corners are, while the rear axle is not far behind you. The slope of the bonnet also means there is no obstruction to your view out in front of you.
The fact that the steering column is not adjustable has never really bothered me. The distance between the ‘wheel and the gear lever is spot on, so all you have to do is move your seat. The pedals are offset to the left, but you quickly get used to it. Once you’ve adjusted your legs, the seating position is lovely.
The modern alternative: 992-series 911 Targa 4
Step into the 992-series Porsche 911 Targa and it is evident you’ve made a near 4-decade jump in terms of technology. Whereas the Carrera 3.2 looks compact and focused (mainly because of the wing), the 992 is notably larger, but is smooth in its elegant design, partially also owing to the Carrera Exclusive Design wheels painted in the exterior colour (Aventurine Green Metallic) of the car, an optional extra.
Specifications:
- Model: 992.1 Porsche 911 Targa 4
- Engine: 3.0-litre, flat-6, turbopetrol
- Power: 283 kW at 6 500 rpm
- Torque: 450 Nm at 1 950 – 5 000 rpm
- Transmission: 8-speed automatic (PDK)
- Weight: 1 730 kg
- 0-100 kph: 4.4 seconds (claimed)
- Top Speed: 289 kph
This modern, suave design continues in the cabin. Any owner of a 992-series 911 variant will feel quite at home. What I especially appreciate with the specification of this model, is the relative lack of driver and driving options. No exhaust button and no rotary dial on the steering wheel. There is a sport button and a damper button – that is it. This is, after all, a Targa 4, which means it does offer all-wheel drive.
Another visual highlight in the cabin is the wood panel that runs across from the passenger side, just below the dashboard, to the right-hand side of the cabin. Another 2, minor options, are the Porsche crest on the headrests and the truffle brown seatbelts. Needless to say, it is a classy cabin.
As expected, you sit satisfyingly low in the car, while the range of adjustment on the seat and steering column makes it a cinch to personalise your driving position.
Start the engine and there’s still that typically raw, flat-6 sound and an all-too-obvious woosh from the turbo. If you pay close attention, you hear how the latter’s whistle changes relative to accelerator inputs.
I head out and quickly the PDK ‘box selects the highest gear as we cruise along for some final pictures. As I lean on the long pedal, the level of torque is instantly impressive – it allows the car to linearly pick up speed without fanfare. Peak torque (450 Nm) is, after all, developed from an impressively low 1 950 rpm. This scenario can immediately be changed by simply pulling the left steering-wheel-mounted paddle.
The gearbox reacts immediately, and within a moment, it’s shifted down 3 or 4 gears. Press the throttle and the engine reacts with a combination of power and torque, having you wonder for a moment if this Targa 4 is really any heavier than a standard Carrera. Even though the road is slightly wet, there is no wheelspin (perhaps thanks to the all-wheel-drive system), but even Porsche’s rear-wheel-drive 911 derivatives offer an immense level of grip – the all-wheel-drive system just takes it up a notch.
It’s a unique experience as the rear of the car squats and propels you out of those corners. At times, (most times) it doesn’t feel like a 1 730 kg car and you can trust the grip and performance.
Even though the peak power output (283 kW) is developed at 6 500 rpm, you can let the rev needle run all the way to the 7 500 rpm redline, urging you to make full use of what the 3.0-litre flat-6 has to offer.
The brakes, meanwhile, are strong with good feedback through the pedal, while the additional ratio in the transmission has little effect on the car’s outright capability, only keeping revs low when you relax on the open road… but now the gears come in quick succession. The steering ratio is fast and the steering feel, in terms of feedback, is less compared to the classic, as you would expect, but nonetheless satisfying.
I know the owner of the 992-series 911 Targa has owned several air-cooled and modern- classic 911s, one of them of which is a rather neat SC, since 1997. But this was the first new 911 in his collection.
“When I saw this 992 Targa it ‘spoke to me’. The design is just perfect, even when the roof is down. I don’t like a convertible and in the Targa, you feel a bit more ensconced. It is like having a large sunroof.
“After acquiring the car earlier this year, I recently attended one of the best driving events in South Africa: the Cape 1000. It is a beautiful multi-day, 1 600-km drive along the Western Cape’s best and prettiest mountain passes. It was the perfect car for the event.” See also: We drive the first-ever Cape 1000!
Without stating the obvious, it is clear that this car will be used regularly for the foreseeable future.
The 8th-gen 911 Targa takes Porsche’s iconic sportscar to the next level in terms of offering compelling performance in conjunction with an al fresco experience. It still drives like a modern 911 (and thus feels charmingly familiar), but offers the latest technology in a package that’s hard to beat, particularly if you consider the performance on offer at this price point. This car instils immense confidence in its driver.
Summary
As with the coupe versions, the 911 Targa is a recipe that Porsche has perfected since the first Targa’s introduction in September 1965.
This latest model ticks so many boxes, but I can understand why many enthusiasts would opt for the G-series Carrera 3.2 Targa. It’s more basic, more involving to drive, much slower but, at times, more fun. It will also need more maintenance to keep on the road, but for some of us, that is part of the experience.
In both cases, you get a driving experience that is very close to that of a coupe, but nearly everything that a convertible offers – it represents a very desirable middle ground. Yes, it’s hard to fault a Targa!
Find a new or used Porsche 911 listed for sale on Cars.co.za
Find exclusive car-themed merchandise at the SentiMETAL Shop
Related content:
Porsche 911 (930) Turbo vs (996) GT3: Classic Comparison
Porsche 911 Turbo SE ‘flat nose’: Classic Drive
Martini Racing 911 Carrera RSR tribute: Classic Drive
SA-built Porsche 911 ‘Safari’: Classic Drive
Porsche 911 (993) GT2: Classic Drive
Porsche 356 vs Porsche 912: Classic Comparison
Porsche 911 Targa ‘Edition 50 Years’ (2022) Launch Review
Porsche 911 GT3 (2022) Launch Review