Cars Awards: Best Fun Car
The winners in the first annual Cars.co.za Consumer Awards will be announced on January 14th. With the finish line in sight, these are the three contenders in the Fun Car category that are battling it out for the prestigious prize. Which one should get the trophy?
For more information on the Cars Awards and the judging panel, head to CarsAwards.co.za
What are we looking for?
What is it that makes a “fun” car? Is it purely about performance and handling? To a degree it is, but for this award we’re looking for a total package without an exorbitant price tag. This is one for the petrolheads – a car that must leave a die-hard enthusiast smiling after every drive. It needs to satifsy in the way it looks, handles, sounds and, yes, performs.
Which cars are eligible?
Its listed price must be below R600 000 at the time of semi-finalist voting (June 17 2015) to ensure that this category doesn’t become dominated by extravagant and unattainable exotics.
Most important judging factors
Drivetrain engagement – more than ultimate performance, a car needs to be reponsive to driver inputs and reward those inputs with immediacy and urgency
Handling – entertaining, crisp dynamics and steering feel/feedback prioritised
Sensory Appeal – a measure of aesthetic appeal and aural stimulation is required
Standard Features – although performance and dynamic prowess are priorities, we’re looking for cars that offer enough comfort and entertainment features to remain a pleasure to drive, even sedately.
Want to have a say?
We appreciate and recognise that owners are the ultimate judges of cars, as they live with them and can attest to the quality of brands' after-sales backup. For that reason, we launched a comprehensive Ownership Satisfaction Survey a few months ago to gain insight into what owners think of their vehicles and their after-sales service experiences. By completing this survey, you will have real impact on the Awards programme. This year, voting has already taken place in the individual product categories, but your input can still have an impact on the Brand of the Year category.
The Finalists
Audi TT 2,0T S tronic
BMW M235i Steptronic
Renault Megane RS Trophy 275
Audi TT 2,0T S tronic
The Audi TT’s main appeal has always been its design and quality interior, rather than performance and dynamics. In its latest incarnation, however, the fun factor has been dialled up significantly. More agile and engaging than ever before, and offering such easily accessible performance and handling, the TT will please both enthusiasts and poseurs. Under the TT’s stubby bonnet is a proven engine that is shared with a large number of VW group products, including the Golf GTI. The 2,0-litre four-cylinder turbo produces169 kW and 370 Nm of torque. The capable, but ultimately dull suspension and steering setups of past TTs have given way to a far crisper, more direct setup that counters understeer well. At the price, the TT’s combination of style, sophistication, performance and features means it already puts forward a very convincing purchasing argument. It’s a properly upmarket package that includes navigation, cruise control, climate control, a sound system with Bluetooth/USB/aux support, auto wipers/lights and even keyless access.
Test Team Opinion
“Even in front-wheel drive configuration the new Audi TT delivers sufficient thrills to be considered a seriously sporting machine. And it does it all with such style and sophistication.” Hannes Oosthuizen
“The latest generation of Audi TT epitomises the sportscar category. Not only is it easy on the eye and brimming with technology, it’s also terrific to drive. Handling is darty and the backfires from the exhaust make for an entertaining combination.” David Taylor
“A front-wheel drive Coupe that somehow manages to mask the negative understeer perceptions. There’s seemingly endless grip and the most responsive dual-clutch gearbox I’ve ever driven.” Ashley Oldfield
BMW M235i Steptronic
What would this shortlist be without a scorching, rear-wheel driven BMW? The M235i Steptronic makes this list because it offers sizzling performance and fun dynamics in a very attractive, high quality package. In many ways it is the modern-day M3, as it offers similar thrills to what made that model so iconic, but at a far more attainable price than a modern-day version. Powering the M235i is one of those straight-line six-cylinder engines that have made BMW the darling of so many enthusiasts. These days turbocharging is used to bump up the power to 240 kW and 450 Nm, but still it retains that silky smooth character of its predecessors. As per usual, this BMW requires the ticking of some option boxes to get the really tasty stuff. That said, it still has auto lights/wipers, a sound system with Bluetooth support and even a cruise control system with active braking as standard. There are lots of extras to choose from too.
Test Team Opinion
“This BMW is so good that it makes one wonder whether it is worth spending more on its illustrious and iconic M3/M4 siblings.” Hannes Oosthuizen
“I’m amazed how close an M235i feels to an M3. As good as the manual gearbox is, we’ve selected the Steptronic which flatters the amateur driver. Acceleration is good, and the handling is very pure. Throw in the addictive six cylinder bark and you have quite a potent machine on your hands.” David Taylor
“Certainly worthy of the baby M title, the M235i commands your attention with superb dynamics and a sweet-sounding backing track. It’s not a car you get bored of driving quickly.” Ashley Oldfield
Renault Megane RS Trophy 275
The hot hatch segment is in rude health at the moment, with the likes of Ford, Volkswagen and Renault all in the running for the crown. It is this special edition Megane RS, however, that really excites us. Whereas contemporary hot hatches attempt to offer a spread of talents that broaden their sales appeal, the Megane RS 275 Trophy is a very focused machine that prioritises ultimate engagement and fun. Under the Renault’s bonnet is a turbocharged 2,0-litre engine that pumps out no less than 201 kW and 360 Nm of torque (the latter across a wide rev range of 3 000 to 5 000 rpm). The power is accessed through a lovely, short-throw six-speed manual gearbox, and sent to the front wheels where a limited slip differential ensures great tractability. Renault always offers lots of standard equipment on all its cars, and this Megane RS Trophy is no different, notwithstanding its hardcore performance orientation. You still get heated front seats, auto lights/wipers, cruise control and a smart info-tainment system with TomTom navigation and Bluetooth.
Test Team Opinion
“It’s refreshing to drive a car that is so single-minded in its purpose. The Megane RS 275 Trophy delivers all the thrills its wild exterior promises.” Hannes Oosthuizen
“If a racecar for the road is what you want, then this will tick all your boxes. It’s very hardcore and the bark from that Akrapovic exhaust will let other road users know that this is a serious machine. Opt for the yellow paintjob for maximum effect.” David Taylor
“I can’t help but need this car in my life, it’s hard-edged and track focused and so responsive to inputs. A proper track car for racers but it’ll make you suffer on the everyday commute with its stiff ride.” Ashley Oldfield